Moderator: 3ne2nr Mods
kamakazi wrote:Not exactly the way I see it... If the oil in the engine is not brought up to temp, it will be similar to doing a short trip... And short trips are classified as severe for a reason
drchaos wrote:kamakazi wrote:Not exactly the way I see it... If the oil in the engine is not brought up to temp, it will be similar to doing a short trip... And short trips are classified as severe for a reason
An engine takes a while to cool down ... The stop start nature of the engine will not cool the car back down to the point that it needs to warm back up. So restarting does not put extra wear on the engine. There was a good article on popular mechanics a few years back talking about stop start technology and what it means for long term reliability.
Its the same with stop start euro's that are not hybrids.
The only thing that takes extra wear is the start motor ... but they are beefed up in hybrids and cars with stop start function.
PariaMan wrote:Remember some hybrid cars can go up to 80 kph before the gas engines kicks in. So stop and start will mostly be on The Electric side. I can see a possible problem with non hybrid but the hybrid it should be ok .
kamakazi wrote:drchaos wrote:kamakazi wrote:Not exactly the way I see it... If the oil in the engine is not brought up to temp, it will be similar to doing a short trip... And short trips are classified as severe for a reason
An engine takes a while to cool down ... The stop start nature of the engine will not cool the car back down to the point that it needs to warm back up. So restarting does not put extra wear on the engine. There was a good article on popular mechanics a few years back talking about stop start technology and what it means for long term reliability.
Its the same with stop start euro's that are not hybrids.
The only thing that takes extra wear is the start motor ... but they are beefed up in hybrids and cars with stop start function.
I hear you but you missed my point entirely... "If the oil in the engine is not brought up to temp" in the first place.
It takes a while (could be more than 10 minutes) to get all the systems to their operating temp in the first place when it only has an internal combustion engine. Any stop start system will add to that.
Can you post a link to that article you are referring to...I tried searching but the only article I found was stop start systems must go... Which is an old article but that is all I found.
@ Pariaman
Would you buy any used vehicle that has its oil changed every 20000kms.
Have to remember that car manufacturers and dealers are also in this business to make money.
Which is cheaper to replace, oil or an engine. Thing is, When it is out of the warranty period... Most people sell their vehicle which is destined to fail sooner rather than later because of these practices... Then it is someone else's problem to deal with
drchaos wrote:kamakazi wrote:drchaos wrote:kamakazi wrote:Not exactly the way I see it... If the oil in the engine is not brought up to temp, it will be similar to doing a short trip... And short trips are classified as severe for a reason
An engine takes a while to cool down ... The stop start nature of the engine will not cool the car back down to the point that it needs to warm back up. So restarting does not put extra wear on the engine. There was a good article on popular mechanics a few years back talking about stop start technology and what it means for long term reliability.
Its the same with stop start euro's that are not hybrids.
The only thing that takes extra wear is the start motor ... but they are beefed up in hybrids and cars with stop start function.
I hear you but you missed my point entirely... "If the oil in the engine is not brought up to temp" in the first place.
It takes a while (could be more than 10 minutes) to get all the systems to their operating temp in the first place when it only has an internal combustion engine. Any stop start system will add to that.
Can you post a link to that article you are referring to...I tried searching but the only article I found was stop start systems must go... Which is an old article but that is all I found.
@ Pariaman
Would you buy any used vehicle that has its oil changed every 20000kms.
Have to remember that car manufacturers and dealers are also in this business to make money.
Which is cheaper to replace, oil or an engine. Thing is, When it is out of the warranty period... Most people sell their vehicle which is destined to fail sooner rather than later because of these practices... Then it is someone else's problem to deal with
It was physical paper magazine which I read back in 2015. The two Audi's with stop start that I rented in the UK in the last two visits had Stop Start but it would not shut off at stopping unless the engine was up to temp.
Not sure if the Hybrids work the same .... good point you making.
The test drive I did with the Ioniq the engine was already up to temp while it kept stopping and starting. Dont know how it would react when cold.
pugboy wrote:U can turn off that eco turn off on feature right ?
All them Porsche come with it
Non local newer hilux
Return to “Ole talk and more Ole talk”
Users browsing this forum: Google [Bot] and 309 guests